| Coverdell Education Savings Account | UGMA/UTMA | Section 529 College plans |
||||||||||||||||
| Definition | Formerly know as the "Education IRA.” Works similarly to a Roth IRA but is earmarked for beneficiaries' education expenses. | The Uniform Gifts/Transfers to Minors Act allows minors to own property. | State-sponsored investment plan designed to encourage saving for college. | |||||||||||||||
| Ownership | Minor (beneficiary) |
Minor (with a custodian) | Account owner | |||||||||||||||
| Investment options | Broad range of investment options. | Broad range of investment options. | Age-based/ years-to- enrollment and static portfolios. Some states also are permitting direct investments into mutual funds. |
|||||||||||||||
| Fees | Fees on mutual funds held in the account are only those charged by the asset- management firm. No additional fees. |
Fees on mutual funds held in the account are only those charged by the asset- management firm. No additional fees. |
Fees on mutual funds held in the account are only those charged by the asset- management firm. No additional fees. |
|||||||||||||||
| Tax benefits | Significant tax benefits if withdrawals are qualified. Investment earnings accumulate federal -income-tax- free until the money is withdrawn. |
If the child is younger than 14, earnings of more than $1,500 on the account are taxed at the parents' rate; if the child is older than 14, the child's tax rate is used. | Significant tax benefits if withdrawals are qualified. Investment earnings accumulate federal- income-tax- free until the money is withdrawn. |
|||||||||||||||
| Financial aid implications | Could negatively affect the child's ability to obtain financial aid. Can still claim HOPE scholarship and Lifetime Learning Credits. | Could negatively affect the child's ability to obtain financial aid. | Less impact on child's ability to obtain financial aid. | |||||||||||||||
| Maximum contribution | $2,000 per year | No limit. | Limit varies according to state statutes. | |||||||||||||||
| Withdrawal requirements | Withdrawals are tax- free. Funds must be used for qualified education expenses (tuition, fees, tutoring, books, supplies, related equipment, room and board, uniforms, transportation, extended day programs, computers, Internet access). |
Withdrawals can be used for any purpose, and no additional penalties or fines are levied. Capital gains are applied to appreciated property when/if sold. | Qualified withdrawals are tax-free. Nonqualified withdrawals are penalized at a 10% federal tax rate (and possibly state tax rate) in addition to the standard federal tax rate of the account holder. | |||||||||||||||
| Pros |
|
|||||||||||||||||
| Cons |
|
|||||||||||||||||
| •Education investment options |
| •Coverdell ESA overview |
| •Open an education account |
| •Coverdell ESA Calculator |
| •Fund information |
| •How to invest |